shippingposition
  • Home
  • News
  • Editorial
    • Vox Pop
  • Maritime safety
  • Oil and Gas
  • Personality
  • Health
No Result
View All Result
shippingposition

Home » How Can Modern Law Combat The Ancient Practice Of Piracy?

How Can Modern Law Combat The Ancient Practice Of Piracy?

by Joshua
August 9, 2009
in Uncategorized

As cases of piracy continue to hit the headlines, what is the position for owners and crew in international and English law?
FORGET images of swashbuckling pirates sailing the high seas in the hope of capturing treasure chests full of gold. The 21st- century reality is far less glamorous.
Piracy remains a serious and increasing problem, notably in the Malacca Straits, South America and West Africa (particularly Nigeria). The latest counts of piracy according to Lloyd’s of London stand at 15 vessels and more than 295 seafarers being held.
In particular, Somalia has one of the worst records of piracy, and it is a problem that is constantly monitored by the International Maritime Organization and the shipping industry.
So far, the international response has been on a two-fold basis: firstly, to assemble naval forces in the affected regions; and secondly, to encourage a political settlement in the fractured state of Somalia. The European Union has now also pledged to tackle piracy with the launch of Operation Atlanta, which will add a further eight vessels to the international effort.
On November 17, the Liberian-flagged very large crude carrier Sirius Star was captured by Somalia pirates and taken into the notorious pirate stronghold of Eyl. The vessel, the biggest tanker ever taken, has over £67m ($100m) worth of oil onboard, representing a quarter of Saudi Arabia’s daily output. It also has 25 crew on board, including two Britons.
Not only has the incident raised issues about crew safety but it has also caused fear that any damage to the Sirius Star could result in an oil pollution disaster on an even larger scale than the Erika or Prestige. On November 20, the pirates issued a ransom demand for $25m, and there are concerns that non-compliance with their demand could have catastrophic consequences.
Acts of piracy are a conflict with the usual principles of exclusive flag-state jurisdiction. Usually, a state will retain jurisdiction over its nationals on a vessel, although since the collision involving the vessel Lotus there is a general expectation that where there is a conflict of two separate jurisdictions, it will be the jurisdiction of the vessel’s flag state that prevails.
That said, there still exists a legal minefield concerning who can obtain jurisdiction over the pirates and bring them to legal account.
An act of piracy undermines the usual principles applying to flag state jurisdiction, as Article 100 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea provides that every state has a duty to act against piracy.
Piracy itself is defined in Unclos Article 101 as “any illegal acts of violence, detention or depredation committed for private ends by the crew or passengers of a private ship against another ship or persons or property onboard it whilst on the high seas”.
The requirement of needing two vessels (pirate and victim) to be involved distinguishes acts of piracy from those of hijacking, and it explains why incidents such as the Achille Lauro and Santa Maria, where passengers took control of the vessels, are not acts of piracy.
Pirate ships on the high seas may be seized by clearly marked warships (or aircraft) or any authorized vessel on government service. Those found onboard a pirate vessel may be tried by any state before whose courts they are brought, and the state may determine by its laws the penalties to be imposed (Unclos Article 105).
However, this course of action should not be taken lightly. Unclos provides that compensation may be payable to a vessel that is incorrectly boarded.
Arguably, the most effective response by international actors would be a bombardment of the stronghold of Eyl. However, such a move could not be brought about without a resolution of the UN Security Council, an outcome that is highly unlikely.
Pirates brought before a court in England and Wales can be prosecuted under the Piracy Act of 1837. While in theory there is nothing to prevent the prosecution of pirates under this Act, there are additional problems.
It is possible that pirates can be extradited, although this may only be done within the considerations of the Human Rights Act.
Taking the example of the Somalian pirates caught by Plymouth-based HMS Cumberland, it is unlikely that they would be extradited back to Somalia (by whatever authority can be found) as the risk of unfair and harsh treatment is extremely high. The pirates were, eventually, handed to Kenya, not Somalia.
On November 20, AP Moller-Maersk announced its adoption of a new policy in respect of its tankers. Vessels will be routed past the Cape of Good Hope, although, depending on the availability of escorts, some vessels may join naval convoys through the Gulf of Aden.
Speculation suggests that this may not overcome the problem, though, as pirates are increasingly capable of extending their catchment’s area and their weapons’ capabilities.
While a decision to avoid the Suez Canal ultimately means higher overheads, which will be passed on to consumers, there will be other long-term implications. Egypt depends on the Suez Canal as its second most important foreign currency earner after tourism.
As levels of piracy rise, ship owners can in turn expect insurance premiums to increase accordingly. The insurance industry is undecided about where piracy risks should lie. There is the power to move this risk between hull and war cover, as proposed by using wording issued by the Joint War and Hull Committees.
If piracy risks rest with hull and machinery cover, it is likely that a member will pay specifically increased premiums for traversing a stretch of water such as the Gulf of Aden, in the same way that increased premiums were fixed in, for example, the Iraq wars.
Furthermore, it is not clear whether ransoms are covered under the scope of a war and terrorism policy or P&I Club terms. Should ship owners be made to pay for a peril, unless there is specific cover?
Lloyd’s List recently reported that Hiscox Insurance Group has highlighted a new scope of insurance. Traditional marine cover will meet the cost of the ransom but none of the costs involved in the process. Ransom can account for just 25%-30% of the costs of the incident. Where kidnap and ransom cover goes above the traditional marine policies is that it will become involved from the moment a vessel is seized.
As to the legality of ransom, there are two potential pitfalls under English law, with the provisions of anti-terror laws and the Proceeds of Crime Act.
Money cannot be paid over to individuals if there is a reasonable belief that the organization is a terrorist one, or if there is a reasonable chance that the funds could end up in the hands of terrorists. Pirates have gone to great lengths to issue statements that they are not affiliated with any terrorist groups.
It is generally anticipated that the payment of ransom equates to extortion, and there is a clear belief that public policy dictates that those who pay ransom demands should be exempt from money- laundering regulations.
There is much debate over the use of armed guards, or even arming members of the crew. The general consensus with the shipping, and indeed, the security industry, is that arming vessels is not a sensible route forward.
Crews who open fire on pirates could escalate a situation to a lethal level. Furthermore, many very large crude carriers are so long in length that it would be impossible to provide adequate levels of security on a cost-effective basis.
The industry is divided on this point, as ship owners require adequate protection but remain responsible for the acts and omissions of their armed and specifically trained sub-contractors.
There must be a sound argument for providing thorough training on counter-attack measures so that crew members will have the confidence to deal with incidents in as non-violent a manner as possible. Charles Hattersley and Polly Russell Stower are members of the marine department at Ashford.

 


Related Posts

Customs Seize Contraband, Destroy Raw Donkey Skin In Adamawa

FG To Shutdown Adeniji/Adekunle Third Mainland Bridge Ramps For Repairs On Monday

November 18, 2023
FG Rakes in N4.3trn From Oil In 2021, N2.3trn In 2023 — Report

FG Rakes in N4.3trn From Oil In 2021, N2.3trn In 2023 — Report

September 25, 2023
Oil Theft: Security Agencies Accuse Mdas, Oil Coys, Communities, Others Of Collusion

ANLCA Elects Emenike Nwokeoji As National President, Promises Unity and Progress

September 8, 2023
International Shipping Companies Threaten To Stop Trading In Nigeria Over Backlog Of Tax Claims

FG Targets N553bn From Unremitted Shipping Taxes

July 6, 2023

Discussion about this post

Latest News

Auto Draft

Immigration Nabs 5, Warns Commercial Boat Operators Against Human Trafficking

December 2, 2023

Shippers’ Council Drives Efficiency in Cargo Movement, Reinforces Collaboration with Lekki Deep Sea Port

IMO Partners Germany To Boost Maritime Security In West And Central Africa

Nigeria’s Membership Of WTO, Bane To Local Market, Domestic Production – Don

30 Personnel Graduate From UNDP Maritime Security Programme

Troops Destroy 51 Illegal Refining Sites, Recover Stolen Crude Oil – DHQ

Vessels Expected At Lagos Ports At As 1st December, 2023

Vessels Expected At Lagos Ports As At 30th November, 2023

CGC Adeniyi Installs New Customs Companies’ Board Members

Nigeria Customs Service Zone ‘A’ Relocates Headquarters to Ikeja

Arsenio Dominguez Velasco Confirmed As Next IMO Secretary-General

Vessels Expected At Lagos Ports As At 29th November, 2023

kindly like our Facebook page

Health

Frequently Asked Questions About Suicide
Health

Frequently Asked Questions About Suicide

November 7, 2023

Suicide is a major public health concern. When a person dies by suicide, the effects are felt by family, friends,...

Some Facts You Need to Know About Stroke

November 2, 2023
Cervical Cancer:  HPV Vaccine Is Safe, Serves As Lifelong Prevention — Minister

Cervical Cancer:  HPV Vaccine Is Safe, Serves As Lifelong Prevention — Minister

November 2, 2023
Blood Pressure, Blood Sugar Tests Critical To Eye Health Care – Optometrist

Blood Pressure, Blood Sugar Tests Critical To Eye Health Care – Optometrist

October 25, 2023
Sex-Enhancing Drugs May Trigger Heart Diseases – Gynaecologist

Sex-Enhancing Drugs May Trigger Heart Diseases – Gynaecologist

October 23, 2023
Depression Alerts To Watch Out For By Everyone

Depression Alerts To Watch Out For By Everyone

October 23, 2023
The ‘Ordeal’ Called Fibroid

The ‘Ordeal’ Called Fibroid

October 17, 2023
ABC Of Mental Health?

ABC Of Mental Health?

October 17, 2023
World Mental Health Day 2023: De-Criminalise Mental Health, Says Minister

World Mental Health Day 2023: De-Criminalise Mental Health, Says Minister

October 17, 2023
The Usefulness In Watermelon Seeds You May Not Know

The Usefulness In Watermelon Seeds You May Not Know

October 9, 2023

© 2021 Shippingposition

Navigate Site

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap
  • Terms

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Coast To Coast
  • Oil and Gas
  • Maritime Education
  • The Terminals
  • Maritime safety

© 2021 Shippingposition