shippingposition
  • Home
  • News
  • Editorial
    • Vox Pop
  • Maritime safety
  • Oil and Gas
  • Personality
  • Health
No Result
View All Result
shippingposition

Home » US Court Says Piracy Includes Failed Attempts

US Court Says Piracy Includes Failed Attempts

by Joshua
May 25, 2012
in Uncategorized

A US federal appeals court made clear on Wednesday that the definition of piracy includes violent attempts to hijack a ship, even if unsuccessful, and upheld convictions against five Somali pirates.
The 4th US Circuit Court of Appeals, based in Richmond, Virginia, upheld what federal prosecutors described as the first US piracy convictions in 190 years, finding that an individual does not have to seize or rob a ship to commit piracy.

A US federal appeals court made clear on Wednesday that the definition of piracy includes violent attempts to hijack a ship, even if unsuccessful, and upheld convictions against five Somali pirates.
The 4th US Circuit Court of Appeals, based in Richmond, Virginia, upheld what federal prosecutors described as the first US piracy convictions in 190 years, finding that an individual does not have to seize or rob a ship to commit piracy.
The court rejected a bid by five Somali men to overturn their convictions for attacking a US Navy ship they mistook for a merchant vessel in 2010.
In April 2010, a small gang of Somali pirates fired on the USS Nicholas, which was lit to disguise itself as a merchant ship while combatting piracy off the coast of Africa.
Approaching on a skiff, the men fired AK-47s at the ship and launched rocket-propelled grenades into the air, but they never managed to board or seize the Navy frigate.
After a pursuit, naval forces captured the pirates and transported them back to the United States to face piracy and related charges. The men were found guilty and convicted to life in prison, the punishment for piracy, plus 80 years.
On appeal, the men argued that their actions did not meet the definition of piracy under the law. They pointed to the Supreme Court's 1820 decision in United States v. Smith, which defined piracy as robbery at sea.
But a unanimous three-judge panel of the 4th Circuit disagreed on Wednesday, citing two international treaties that define piracy to encompass acts of violence.
“The definition of piracy under the law of nations, at the time of the defendants' attack on the USS Nicholas and continuing today, had for decades encompassed their violent conduct,” Judge Robert King wrote for the panel.
David Bouchard, a lawyer for the defendants, said his clients were prepared to appeal the case to the Supreme Court. He said the Supreme Court's 1820 definition still applied, and that the United States has never ratified the Geneva Convention on the High Seas or the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, which the 4th Circuit cited.
In a separate decision, the 4th Circuit also ruled in a different case stemming from an attack on the USS Ashland by five other men from Somalia. In that case, a judge had dismissed the piracy counts against those defendants, concluding that because the men had not taken control of the ship or committed robbery, their actions did not constitute piracy. The 4th Circuit reversed that ruling on Wednesday, sending the case back to the lower court for further proceedings.
Geremy Kamens, a lawyer for the defendants in that case, did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
“Today, the Fourth Circuit made clear that anyone who attempts an armed hijacking of another vessel on the high seas is a pirate under US law,” US Attorney Neil MacBride said in a statement. – Reuters


Related Posts

Meningitis: Death Toll In Kebbi Hits 56 – Govt 

Meningitis: Death Toll In Kebbi Hits 56 – Govt 

March 24, 2025
Navy Rescues 8 Police Officers,1 Civilian From Boat Accident In Bayelsa

Navy Rescues 8 Police Officers,1 Civilian From Boat Accident In Bayelsa

January 8, 2025
PHOTO NEWS: SIFAX Thanksgiving and Night of Praise 2.0

PHOTO NEWS: SIFAX Group Thanksgiving and Night of Praise 2.0

December 18, 2024
NEPC Frowns at $480m Expenditure on Importation of 3m Tonnes of Rice Importation

Eastern Ports Set for Boost in Investments as Dantsoho Tours Onne and Rivers Port Complexes

December 6, 2024

Discussion about this post

Latest News

IMO ELECTIONS: Oyetola Flags Off Nigeria’s Election Campaign in London

IMO ELECTIONS: Oyetola Flags Off Nigeria’s Election Campaign in London

June 20, 2025

Centre Urges FG to harmonise AfCFTA Strategies For Speedy Implementation 

APFFLON Calls for Urgent Reform of Nigeria Police Force

Vessels Expected At Lagos Ports As At 19th June, 2025

Dantsoho Front Lines Human Capital Development As NPA Promotes 1,500 Employees

Navy Arrests 3 Suspected Oil Thieves In Delta

Workers’ Welfare: Maritime union issues 21-day ultimatum to Melsmore

Customs Intercept Guns, 1,433 Live Cartridges In Ogun

Maritime Police, Clearing Agents Task Force Forge Alliance to Tackle Port Corruption, Economic Sabotage

Vessels Expected At Lagos Ports As At 18th June, 2025

Adeyanju Commends MWUN Over Election of New Executives of Shipping Branch

IPMAN Urges Reversal Of Truck Parking Fee

kindly like our Facebook page

Health

Why Prostate Disorder Cases Are Increasing Among Nigerian Men – Experts
Health

Why Prostate Disorder Cases Are Increasing Among Nigerian Men – Experts

June 1, 2025

Association of Medical Laboratory Scientists of Nigeria, Lagos State chapter, has raised the alarm over the increasing number of men...

20m Nigerians Live With Mental Health Issues, Says WHO

20m Nigerians Live With Mental Health Issues, Says WHO

June 1, 2025
Health Facts You Didn’t Know

How Your Habit Affects Fertility

May 19, 2025
Fruits For Raining Season

Fruits For Raining Season

May 19, 2025
See Mental Illness Like Other Treatable Diseases – Says Suicide Survivor

Health Facts You Didn’t Know

May 19, 2025
Alligator Pepper: Benefits, FAQ, Side Effects, & Warning

Alligator Pepper: Benefits, FAQ, Side Effects, & Warning

April 28, 2025
Water And Health: The Relationship That Helps Life

Water And Health: The Relationship That Helps Life

April 28, 2025
Some Truths and Myths About Agbo Herbal Concoction

Some Truths and Myths About Agbo Herbal Concoction

April 21, 2025
The Malaise Of Misuse of Antibiotics

The Malaise Of Misuse of Antibiotics

April 14, 2025
Urologist Debunks Breast-Cancer Prevention Myth

Urologist Debunks Breast-Cancer Prevention Myth

April 14, 2025

© 2021 Shippingposition

Navigate Site

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap
  • Terms

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Coast To Coast
  • Oil and Gas
  • Maritime Education
  • The Terminals
  • Maritime safety

© 2021 Shippingposition